Home › Guides › Battery or alternator?

Battery or alternator?

Replacing a perfectly good battery because the alternator stopped charging is the most common wasted purchase in this trade.

The pattern that points at the battery

The car struggles to start after standing, especially overnight or in the cold, but once it is running it runs normally. Lights are steady while you drive. Jump-start it and it behaves for the rest of the day, then struggles again the next morning.

That is a battery losing capacity.

The pattern that points at the alternator

The car starts perfectly on a jump and then dies while you are driving, or within twenty minutes. The battery warning light stays on with the engine running. Headlights dim and brighten with engine speed. Sometimes there is a whine that rises with revs.

A new battery in that car will be flat again within days, and it will not be a warranty claim.

The pattern that points at neither

The engine cranks at a normal speed and simply will not fire. The battery is doing exactly its job. The problem is fuel, spark, a sensor or the immobiliser, and anybody who sells you a battery at that point has not looked.

The check that settles it

A charging-system test reads what the alternator is actually delivering at the battery with the engine running and a load applied. It takes about as long as the battery test and we do both together, because selling somebody a battery for an alternator fault is a complaint waiting to happen.

Both tests are free. If it is the alternator, we will tell you so, and we do not sell alternators.

Find your battery

Which battery does your car take?

Read the code off the top or side of your current battery — three digits, sometimes with letters after them, like 628 or 646.

Looking for a battery, not a franchise? You are in the right place. Find your nearest store for prices, hours and directions, or see the Novax® range.

Where to go from here

Every Global Batteries Xpress store tests your battery and your charging system free of charge, quotes in writing before any work starts, fits while you wait and sends your old battery to a licensed recycler at no cost to you.